• May 2013
    M T W T F S S
    « Nov    
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    2728293031  

Funny ads for the exhibition ‘World of the Celts’ in Stuttgart

The state museum of archaeology in Stuttgart is showing a special exhibition ‘The World of the Celts‘. You can go and see it until 17th of February next year.

On this occasion they published some funny Videos. Although the Celtic warriors appear a tad too barbaric, the videos are  quite some eye-catchers :)

Free access articles from PNAS

This week’s PNAS early edition (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences) for 29th October 2012 offers some really interesting articles as open access articles:

  • Joaquim Fort, University of Girona, Spain looks at the Neolithic transition models (demic and cultural model) of the European Neolithic transition from a physicist’s viewpoint: Synthesis between demic and cultural diffusion in the Neolithic transition in Europe’ (PNAS article)
  • Michael Storey from the Roskilde University in Denmark and his colleagues succeeded in a much more precise dating of the Toba supereruption in Sumatra by 40Ar/39Ar dating of sanidine crystals. Apart from a global synchronization for a time period beyond the range of 14C dating they also reflect on the consequences for the peopling of Southeast Asia by Homo sapiens. (PNAS article)
  • Jean-Jacques Hublin and team from the Max-Planck-Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig report new radiocarbon dates from the Grotte du Renne and Saint-Césaire which support an Neanderthal origin of the Châtelperronian. They also demonstrate that the Neanderthal production of body ornaments postdate the arrival of modern humans in neighbouring areas and therefore is probably based on cultural diffusion (PNAS article)
  • Also of interest is an article by William Forde Thompson and al. (Macquarie University, Sydney) about a musical protolanguage hypothesis: music and language share mechanisms that trigger emotional responses to acoustic attributes, as predicted by theories that propose a common evolutionary link (PNAS article)
  • Michael Knapp et al. from the Departments of Anatomy and Anthropology and Archaeology at the University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand present a complete mitochondrial genome sequence from the likely founding population of Aotearoa/New Zealand, recovered from the site of Wairau Bay. Their data provide some insights into the genetic diversity of human populations in the Pacific at the time of the settlement of East Polynesia (PNAS article)

Quite an offer :) Thank you PNAS!

The Durham Archaeological Museum ‘Old Fulling Mill’ and a bit of fulling history

In Durham there stands an old fulling mill besides the River Wear. But long before this one, there was an older fulling mill there; a mill from the 12th century, to be exact, because around this time the mill dam was mentioned for the first time.

mill dam in Durham

In the 15th century there were even two fulling mills which were owned by the Bishop of Durham and later by the cathedral’s Prior. The money gained from the fulling mill was used for the upkeep of the Jesus Altar in Durham Cathedral. By 1771 there was only one mill left, the so-called Abbey Mill. In the 19th century the mill was referred to as the Old Fulling Mill and was in use till 1833 when it was turned into the first university museum of Durham.

The ‘Old Fulling Mill’ in Durham

But before I show you some artefacts exhibited in the museum, I would like to have a closer look with you at a fulling mill or rather the process of fulling itself.

Before the groundbreaking invention of the waterpowered fulling mill, fulling was a time consuming workload.

The first indication of fulling wool comes from Cyprus, from the Late Neolithic (5th millenium BC) site of Ayios Epiktitos-Vrysi where lumps of fuller’s earth have been found scattered about the site in built plaster containers (Robertson 1986). Fulling has also been proposed as an option for the use of the so-called fulachta fiadh in Bronze Age Ireland (Jeffrey 1991; Denvir 1999 (?); Downes and Thomas 2008):

Possible function of burnt mounds (Irish: fulachta fiadh) in textile production
from: Jeffrey 1991, fig. 2

With written evidence, wool production and trade is much easier to follow.

Whereas woolen cloth was not very popular in Ancient Egypt before the Greco-Egyptian period (a washing powder for wool is for example mentioned in the 4th century AD Stockholm papyrus as is the use of  ’fuller’s plant’ or ‘fuller’s herb’ (Jensen 2008), the wool cloth industry boomed in Mesopotamia and became a tremendously important economic factor not only as export good but also as ration (‘payment’) par excellence (Good 2007, 151; Veenhof 1972, 79-88 and 130; Algaze 2008, 82). Economic texts from the Ur III period (early third millenium BC) describe the textile industry under Ibbi-Sin, the last king of the Ur III period, and give a hint of its importance within the royal economy. In Ebla the house of wool (é-siki) was synonym with the treasury (Andersson et al. 2010, 160).

Bolts of wool were repeatedly washed, rolled, pounded, and trampled, as well as repeatedly treated with oils and alkalines (i.e. soap) and repeatedly rinsed in water in order to shrink and strengthen the cloth in preparation for dying (Algaze 2008, 85f.). Until the invention of fuller mills, the process seems not to have changed dramatically through time. The church of Notre Dame in Semur-en-Auxois has a 15th century stained glass window which illustrates the process quite nicely:

Waetzoldt (1972, 159) examined the work load connected with the process of fulling. According to his studies, to obtain 1 kg of low quality wool, a late third millenium fuller at Lagash spent 6.6 workdays (a workday being 12h per day). A high quality wool needed 71-81 workdays (!). This of course excludes all other steps of the production process like pasturing the sheep, plucking the wool, washing the wool to remove dirt and lanolin, sorting and separating the cleaned wool according to quality and colour, transport of the wool to storehouses, combing (carding) the wool to prepare it for spinning, spinning the wool, dyeing the yarn where applicable, delivering the yarn to the weavers, weaving, colouring of the whole cloth after fulling (Algaze 2008, 86-7). Not surprisingly, the learning of the trade itself required an apprenticeship of 6 years (Sayce 1924, 70).

While in Mesopotamia and later in Egypt a kind of soap, made from oil and potash in a 1:5.5 ratio with the occasional addition of soapy plants like soapwort or asphodill (Waetzoldt 1972, 158) was used, this knowledge was not transmitted into the Roman period.  According to Pliny the Elder, soap was a Celtic invention; he described soap as an invention of the Gauls, made of suet, ash (with beech tree being the most suitable), and goat’s milk (Pliny the Elder, Historia Naturalis xxviii, 191). Romans used other substances, for example lixivium (an alkaline  solution obtained by leaching wood ash with water), nitrum (soda ash = sodium carbonate), creta fullonia (fuller’s earth , a very fine-grained clay with water content), alkaline marl (a lime-rich mud) and human or animal urine.

Human urine was collected in dolia curta, earthenware urinals, placed along the streets for the conveniance of the Roman male population. Interestingly, a urinal vessel has been found in a Roman fullery in Schwarzenacker, Germany:

matula (night potty) from a latrine belonging to a fullery in Schwarzenacker, Germany
© Saaländischer Museumsverband e.V.

http://saarland.digicult-museen.net

In ancient Rome, the fuller’s trade was at least as important as in Mesopotamia: It included the processes starting from the cleaning and walking (fulling) of raw wool, the colouring, and the cleaning and pressing of worn clothes.

In Pompeii several buildings were dedicated to the cloth industry. The most famous is the fullonica (fullery) of Stephanus (Reg I, Ins 6, 7), mainly because it re-used a posh former residence with an atrium (open central court in a villa). The former impluvium (rain catchment basin) was converted into a washing/fulling basin (for a convincingly different view on re-use of atrium houses see Flohr 2011b).

fullery of Stephanus animation

In the peristyle (an open courtyard or garden surrounded by a colonnade) of the fullonica of L. Veranius Hypsaeus (Reg I, Ins V.8.20) there were paintings which related to the fullery’s daily chores (now in the museum of Naples). Among other scenes it depicts the process of either fulling the woven textiles in basins or dyeing them.

© Barbara McManus, VRoma Image Archive, University of Arizona
http://www2.cnr.edu/home/araia/work.html

Re-investigations between 2006 and 2008 (Flohr 2011) showed that many similar workshops were also dedicated to the cloth industry. Most were probably cleaners but some had heatable vats, too, and could either re-dye cloth or were full wool processing workshops (e.g. Reg. VI Ins. XVI. 3.4).

water basins and vats in a cleaning shop
Pompeii Reg V, Ins. I.4
© Julia Kruse
Heatable vats, probably for dyeing
Pompeii, cleaning shop Reg V, Ins. I.4
© Julia Kruse

In other Roman cities the situation was not much different. In Ostia, too, there are large numbers of fulleries producing cloth and tending to textiles (Flohr 2011).

Here you can see some real stalls with their dividing walls from a workshop in Ostia:

Fullery behind the temple of the ship carpenters, Ostia
from: De Ruyt 2001, fig. 3

Fulleries were known for their stench, after all rotting urine (see above) for cleaning and sulphur for bleaching the cloth were used.

Bradley (2002, 37-8) writes about health problems due to exposure  to detergents like dermatitis and lung problems because of the burning of sulphur. While these health risks can be readily accepted because of the prevalent conditions of work, pathological prove is difficult. However, other work related strains and illnesses can actually be proved, thanks to a recent excavation in Casal Bertone near Rome (Musco et al 2008). A large scale fullery (or possibly a tannery) with several large basins, 90 vats, further 44 dolia (large earthenware containers) as well as drainage canals which divided the compound into several production areas.

Overview over excavated area in Casal Bertone
modified from: Musco et. al. 2008, figure on page 36

Even more intersting is the fact that there is a cemetery contemporaneous with the fullery and a large mausoleum connected to the site. 166 individulas haven been studied so far and palaeopathological investigations interestingly showed signs of alterations which are consistent with those to be expected when working in a fullery:

Illustration of the body parts subjected to alterations caused by arduous work
Musco et al. 2008, figure on page 39

As already mentioned, the process involved in the production of cloth did not change very much through times. However, in the late 12th century, monks were at the fore front of a minor ‘industrial revolution’ that saw the introduction of fulling mills into Britain. The introduction of water technology revolutionised the fulling process. In AD 1185 two mills were set up by Knights Templars in Temple Newsham, West-Yorkshire and Barton-on-Windrush, Gloucestershire, respectively. Through the monastic ‘information network’ the technology quickly spread beyond the Brithish Isles.

In a fulling mill the cloth was beaten with wooden mallets in a trough, usually in three steps. The first one with stale urine, the second with fuller’s earth, and the third one with hot soapy water. Each step lasted around two hours with additional time for rinsing.

The pounding of the cloth obviously created a great deal of noise and thus a fulling mill could be heard from great distances. And this noise went on and on for centuries; even Don Quixote had to suffer under the constant clamour of the mills:

They [Don Quixote and Sancho] had gone about a hundred yards farther, when at doubling a point, the very cause, for it could be no other, of that horrible and dreadful noise, which had held them all night in such suspense and fear, appeared plain exposed to view.

It was, kind reader take it not in dugeon, six fulling-hammers, whose alternate strokes fromed that hideous sound. Don Quixote, seeing what it was, was struck dumb, and in the utmost confusion.”

Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra 1605, translated

by Charles Jarvis (Jervis), London 1819, Part I, Chapter VI

Durham’s fulling mill, one of the earliest fulling mills in the country, still honours the wool production in its exhibitions. The upper floor is dedicated to wool, rare species of sheep and modern products manufactored in the old traditions.

Felted woolen sarcophagus, Durham Museum of Archaeology

References:

Algaze, G. 2008. Ancient Mesopotamia at the Dawn of Civilization, Chicago.

Andersson, E., Felluca, E., Nosch, M-L., and Peyronal, L. 2010. New Perspectives on Bronze Age Textileproduction in the Eastern Mediterranean. The First Results with Ebla as a Pilot Study, In Matthiae et al. 2010, Proceedings of the 6th International Congresson the Archaeologyof the Ancient Near East, Wiesbaden 2010, 159-76.

Bradley, 2002. It all comes out in the wash: Looking harder at the Roman fullonica, Journal of Roman Archaeology 15, 20-44.

Denvir, A.-M. 1999 (?). Fulachta Fiadh – An Irish Mystery. Online article based on BA dissertation. http://www.angelfire.com/fl/burntmounds/

Downes, J. and Thomas, A. 2008. An Integrated landscape approach to prehistoric sheep husbandry and wool production in Northern Europe. Draft paper to accompany 10-minute presentation at WAC-6. link

De Ruyt, C. 2001. Les foulons, artisans des textiles et blanchisseurs. In: Descoeudres, J-P. (ed.) 2001. Ostia – port et porte de la Rome, Geneva.

Flohr, M. 2011a. Cleaning the Laundries III. Report on the 2008 campaign, The Journal of Fasti Online, Folder 214. http://www.fastionline.org/docs/FOLDER-it-2011-214.pdf

Flohr, M. 2011b. Reconsidering the atrium House: Domestic fullonicae at Pompeii. In: Poehler, E., Flohr, M., and K. Cole, 2011. Art, Industry and Infrastructure, Oxford.

Jeffrey, S. 1991. Burnt mounds, fulling and early textiles. In: Hodder, I. and Barfield, L.-H. (eds.) 1991. Burnt mounds and hot stone technology, Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council, 97-108.

Jensen, W. B. (ed.) 2008. The Leyden and Stockholm Papyri, translated by Earle Radcliffe Caley, University of Cincinnati, Ohio, USA. http://www.che.uc.edu/jensen/W.%20B.%20Jensen/Books/Leyden%20&%20Stockholm%20Papyri.pdf

Musco, St. 2008. Le complexe archéologique de Casal Bertone, Les Dossiers d’ Archéologie 330, 32-9.

Pliny the Elder, The Natural History (Historia Naturalis), translated by J. Bostock et al. http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=urn:cts:latinLit:phi0978.phi001.perseus-eng1:1.dedication

Robertson, R. H. S 1986. Fuller’s earth: A history of calcium montmorillonite (Mineralogical Society occasional publication), Hythe, UK. (Cited in Denvir 1999).

Sayce, A. H. 1924. Babylonians and Assyrians. Life and Customs, New York.

Veenhof, K. R. 1972. Aspects of Old Assyrian Trade and its Terminology. Studia et Documenta vol. X, Leiden.

Waetzoldt, H. 1972. Untersuchungen zur neusumerischen Textilindustrie, Rome.

 

Weblinks:

The fulleries in Ostia: http://www.ostia-antica.org/dict/topics/fullones/fullones.htm

Miko Flohr’s webpage: http://www.mikoflohr.nl/archaeology/

The Old Fulling Mill Museum of Archaeology in Durham : http://www.dur.ac.uk/fulling.mill/

Anne-Maire Denvir’s webpage on Fulachta Fiadh: http://www.angelfire.com/fl/burntmounds/

Fullonica of Stephanus in Pompeii: https://sites.google.com/site/ad79eruption/pompeii/regio-i/reg-i-ins-6/fullonica-of-stephanus

Pompeii in pictures: http://pompeiiinpictures.com/pompeiiinpictures/index.htm

 

 

 

The Early Upper-Palaeolithic edge-ground stone axes of Japan

A new publication by Takashi TSUTSUMI (2012), published in Quaternary International (unfortunately  filed under his first name Takashi), examines edge-ground stone axes which belong to the early Upper Palaeolithic of the Japanese archipelago, their possible uses, and their importance for the question of when the first modern humans arrived in Japan. He especially draws on his work at the Hinatabayashi B site. Edge-ground axes were first discovered in 1949 at the site of Iwajuku. However, their connection to the Palaeolithic wasn’t readily recognized and they were instead attributed to a pre-ceramic Neolithic by Yamanouchi (Yamanouchi and Sato 1962). This was mainly based on a comparison with European polished axes. Only large-scale excavations from the 1970s onwards allowed a more precise dating and their attribution to the Palaeolithic period.

In Europe pottery vessels are markers for Neolithic cultures; so are polished stone axes. While some ground stone axes can be found in the later Mesolithic of Ireland (Woodman 1978) and Wales like these from Nab Head II (David 1989) in Wales no earlier ground stone axes are known in Europe.

Ground stone axes from Nab Head II

In Japan, however, the situation is different. While modern humans (Homo sapiens) only arrived around 40,000 BP on the Japanese archipelago, it wasn’t before long that they began to experiment with lithic technology. Soon the first edge-ground axes (局部磨製石斧(きょくぶませいせきふ) appeared. The earliest ones are from Ishinomoto site 石の本遺跡 in Hirayama, near Kumamoto on Kyushu. Radiocarbon dated charcoal associated with these axes gave dates between 35,000 and 32,000 cal BP (Takashi 2012, 73).

This innovation rapidly spread throughout Kyushu and Honshu. Although seafaring was practiced at this time the Okinawan islands as well as Hokkaido are interestingly void of edge-ground axes.

Distribution of early Early Upper Palaeolithic (eEUP) sites in the Japanese Archipelago (Tsutsumi 2012, fig. 3)

The basis for dating these edge-ground axes are quite solid with the well-dated Aira-Tn tephra (AT) that covers all of Kyushu, Shikoku, and Honshu. The high precision 14C age for the AT tephra is 25,120 ± 270 BP (Miyairi et al. 2004). The tephra marks the boundary between the Early Upper Palaeolithic (EUP) beneath the tephra band and the Later Upper Palaeolithic (LUP) above the tephra band. All edge-ground axes are from strata below the Aira-Tn tephra. Radiocarbon dates associated with charcoal from several sites confirm a dating to the EUP.

To give you some examples with rough dates (for exact dates see Tsutsumi Takashi 2012, 73 and table 1):

Site

cal. Radiocarbon Dates BC

Ishinomoto

38,500 – 35,800

Fuji-ishi

36,500

Hinatabayashi B

35,000 – 32,000

Umenokizawa

35,000 – 31,000

Mukoda

34,000 – 33,700

Apart from serpentine stone used for edge ground axes, andesite, chalcedony, and obsidian provided the raw material for flake tools. They show very clearly the existence of a wide trading network and even the beginning of expeditions to exploit certain territories. Obsidian, for example, must have been brought in from at least more than 40 km and the Kozu Island Obsidian from  even further away, namely about 100 km into the Pacific, reachable only by boat.

To decide upon the usage of these axes Tsutsumi looked at the available use wear data (Sahara 1993, Tsutsumi 2006, Takahashi 2004, Iketani 2004) as well as conducting additional studies on 36 axes from Hinatabayashi B. It is interesting to note that all the  chipped axes found at Hinatabayashi B did not show any traces of use wear. Tsutsumi therefore concludes that these are unfinished products. The  larger edge-ground axes which showed signs of heavy work, were most probably used for felling trees and modifying wood. Smaller axe heads which showed few evidence of damage on the blades display  the characteristic luster that comes from processing hide.

Use wear on a stone axe from Hinatabayashi B. Polish from working hide (Takashi 2012, fig 8)

This is well in accordance with vegetation reconstructions for this time period. At Hinatabayashi B for example, pollen records show that  Picea (spruce), Abies (firs), and Tsuga (hemlock) prevailed around Lake Nojiri (Kudo & Kumon 2012, 29) and were used as fire wood. Today, this type of vegetation can be found at 1500 – 2500 m asl, but conditions at the EUP were colder and therefore these kinds of forests could be found around Lake Nojiri (650 m asl).

Especially flake tools of type E and F  suggest hunting activity; use-wear analyses showed that they were used for cutting meat but also for stabbing as in a thrusting-spear. However, although Naumann’s elephants (Palaeoloxodon naumanni) and giant deer (Sinomegaceros yabei) were present in Honshu, fossils of these large animals are scarce and kill sites of the EUP (40 – 30 ka BP) unknown (but see Anthropology and Archaeology Research Group for Nojiri-ko Excavation (ed.),  Study on the Paleolithic Sites around Lake Nojiri (野尻湖周辺の人類遺跡), The memoirs of the Geological Society of Japan (19), 215-249, 1980 and http://www.avis.ne.jp/~nojiriko/nojirikojin.html).

Giant deer and Naumann’s elephant

On the other hand some 50 trap pits are known from a wide range of sites dated to the Early Upper Palaeolithic. Hatsunegahara 初音ヶ原 (Ono et al. 2002, 480) from about 27 to 25 ka BP is one of the largest trap sites, featuring 60 pit traps; even older is the site of Ôtsubobata with 12 pits dating to 30 ka BP (Yamamato & Kawaguchi 2009).

trap pit hunting (Sato 2012, fig. 4)

These traps were used simultaneously and were carefully laid within the game trail that lead down to the valley.

Distribution of trapping pits (Tanegashima). The white arrows indicate the direction of the game trail.
http://archaeology.jp/sites/2009/02otsubobata.htm

The altogether twelve pit traps in Otsubobata on the island of Tanegashima have been closed by the Tane IV ash layer and thus gave the possibility of quite accurate dating, since the Tane IV ash layer is dated (30.5 ka BP).

Where did these Palaeolithic hunter-gatherers live?

Several larger group campsites (some up to 80 m in diameter) have been studied. They consist mostly of large circular or oval areas with a central open space and huts or tents distributed around it.

This is how it is imagined how such a circular campsite might have looked like; it is an artistic view of the  Kambayashi site 上林遺跡 (30-20,700 BP) based on stone artefact distributions. It is estimated to have provided space for 50 to 100 people or about 10 families.

Artistic rendering of the Kambayashi campsite
http://tetsuyuki-fukumoto.art.coocan.jp/

Campsites are usually built on river terraces or slopes overlooking a water source which would have also been their hunting ground.

However, this view has recently been challenged by Takanori SAKASHITA (2010) who studied the site of Tana Mukaihara 田名向原遺跡 (19-23,000 calBP). The results of the re-excavation showed that thermally altered obsidian artifacts are not only concentrated around the hearths, but also in the post holes, suggesting that the so-called post holes indeed functioned as hearths. On the other hand, cooking stones and other material from the two larger central hearths could still have been used as stabilizer for posts as a secondary usage or the ‘post holes’ could indeed have been smaller fire places associated with light tents (which would not have left any traces).  A re-examination of other circular campsites would be necessary to decide which interpretation would be more appropriate.

References:

David, A 1989. Some Aspects of the human presence in west Wales during the Mesolithic. In: Bonsall, C (ed.) The Mesolitic in Europe, Edinburgh, 1989, 241-53.

Iketani, K., 2004. Use-wear analysis of the axe-shaped tools from the Ryusuijiura site. Ryusuijiura Site, pp. 162-180, Inbagun City Archaeological Center (in Japanese). Cited by Takashi 2012.

Kudo, Y  Kumon, F 2012. Paleolithic cultures of MIS 3 to MIS 1 in relation to climate changes in the central Japanese islands, Quaternary International 248, 22-31. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2011.02.016

Miyairi, Y et al. 2004. Improved 14C dating of tephra layer (AT tephra, Japan) using AMS on selected organic fractions, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 223-224, 2004, 555-8. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nimb.2004.04.103

Ono, A, Sato, H, Tsutsumi, T and Kudo, Y 2002. Radiocarbon Dates and Archaeology of the Late Pleistocene in the Japanese Islands, Radiocarbon 44 (2), 477-94. Available here.

Sahara, M 1993. The Cultural History of Axes, Tokyo (in Japanese).

Sakashita, T 2010. Assessing the Reality of a Palaeolithic “Dwelling Structure” in the Japanese Archipelago: The Structure of the Tana-Mukaihara Site, Asian Perspectives 49 (2), 318-31.

Takahashi, S., 2004. Use-wear analysis of the stone axes from the Minamisanrizuka Miyabara 1 site.Inbagun City Archaeological Center (in Japanese). Cited in Takashi 2012.

Takashi, Tsutsumi 2012. MIS3 edge-ground axes and the arrival of the first Homo sapiens in the Japanese archipelago, Quaternary International248, 2012, 70-78. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2011.01.030

Tsutsumi, T 2006. The function of Upper Palaeolithic axes, Journal of Nagano Archaeological Association 118, 1-12 Nagano Archaeological Association (in Japanese).

Woodman, PC 1978. The Mesolithic in Ireland, BAR British Series 58.

Yamamoto, K & Kawaguchi, M 2009. Ôtsubobata: The oldest pit traps in Japan?, online at http://archaeology.jp/sites/2009/02otsubobata.htm (Accessed 10.06.12)

Yamanouchi, S & T Sato 1962. Jomon doki no furusa [The antiquity of Jomon pottery], Kagaku yomiuri 14 (12), 21-6 and 84-8.

Wang Zhaojun Museum’s Complex, Hohhot, Inner Mongolia, China

South of Hohhot you can find the museum’s complex Wang Zhaojun. It consists of several museums, galleries, monuments, and other installations around the supposed burial mound of Wang Zhaojun, a Han royal concubine who was married to the Mongolian Khan Chanyu Huhanye. The mound, also called the Green Mound, allegedly stays green even though all the other grass around it become yellow. Whether it really contains the coffin of Wang Zhaojun is not known, since it has never been excavated. There are nine similar tombs in Mongolia after all.

Burial Mound of Wang Zhaojun

Wang Zhaojun left China and the court of emperor Yan in 33 BC only 17 years old to marry the king of the Huns. This story left of course room for adaptations and thus countless poems, novels, and dramas were written and performed, featuring poor Zhaojun who left the civilized world and led a life of a living death for the peace of her country. To reconstruct her life is, however, difficult since a lot of different life stories of her exist and her life was fictionalised as early as the Tang period.

Whether she really suffered silently for her country is of course unknown, too. On the other side of the border she is often depicted with her husband riding out happily. Maybe she was homesick but she was also a queen of large country; a status she would have never reached back in China where she only was a concubine in waiting.

Wang Zaojun and Chanyu Huhanye

If you are interested in the exterior of the huge area (133,000 m²), you should go to my other blog; here I will rather show you some items from the museums, since Mongolian or Xiongnu archaeology, as it is called, are quite rare to see on Western language blogs.

The smaller museum was concerned with showing some typical grave goods that would have been common during the time Zhaojun’s mound was erected. Many of them are copies from artifacts of the Inner Mongolian Museum in Hohhot. Since we weren’t able to visit this museum due to time constricts, these replicas will have to do :)

Cross section through a Han period burial mound

 

The larger Xiongnu Heritage Museum had a more diverse exhibition, ranging from graves to petroglyphs of the steppe-nomads to weapons of the Huns.

Museum for Xiongnu Culture (Hun Heritage Museum)

The entrance hall is dominated by life size figurines of Wang Zhaojun, her husband Chanyu Huhanye, as well as variant figures in Hun costume:

Entrance Hall of the Xiongnu Heritage Museum

In 1979/80 a Western Han Dynasty cemetery was found in Maoqing Gully near the town of Ulanqab. Excavated were so far 81 graves all with rich grave goods; bronze and iron weapons, horse harnesses and bones from cattle, horse, and sheep.

On the photo you can see the well-preserved belt buckle as well as the bronze dagger.

Grave from Maoqing Gully (Western Han Dynasty)

The Mandela rock art group consist of around 4600 petroglyphs, distributed in an area of 18 km².

Here you can see a hunting scene; the hunter also brought his horse. The associated sign attributed this particular style to the Spring and Autumn period (720 – 481 BC) or Warring States period (475 – 221 BC).

How important the horse was to the Xiongnu population is visible in every detail. There was no exception in death; many graves were equipped with complete horse harnesses. Here is a nice detail from a harness:

Part of a horse harness (Han Dynasty)

This tiger-and-camel plaque was also part of a horse harness:

Copy of a Plaque from a Horse Harness (Han Dynasty)

Angono Petroglyphs, Binangonan, Rizal, Philippines

Die deutsche Version befindet sich hier.

During our summer holidays in the Philippines we spent some time in Manila and since you simply can’t stay on the main island Luzon without having visited the tentative (but not yet) Unesco World Heritage site of the Angono Petroglyphs we went on a small trip (it is just 2.5 to 3 hours from Manila) to the rock shelter of Angono.

The Angono rock shelter near Angono, Rizal, Luzon, Philippines was discovered in 1965 by the artist Carlos ‘Botong’ Francisco on a field trip with boy scouts. The significance of this petroglyph site was immediately recognized and recording of the petroglyphs as well as excavation of the rock shelter started in the same year. In 1998 a small museum was built to emphasize the cultural value of the site. Since 1993 it was submitted to the tentative list of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention.

Contrary to the description on the Unesco website it is not a cave but a rock shelter of about 63 m length and up to 5 m height.

The engravings are basically spread on a 25 m long and 3 m high panel and carved into the volcanic tuff. 127 anthropomorphic figures have so far been identified. There are also geometrical motifs like triangles, rectangles, or circles.

Some figures use existing cracks and forms like this one; one leg is actually the side of a small cavern.

Geometric figures:

Up to present these are the oldest engravings that have been found in the Philippines; the only other site with engravings, Alab, Bontoc, Mountainprovince in Northern Luzon are of much later date (after 1500 BC), if they are indeed connected to the coffin burials in a cave below the Alab rock shelter.

Not only engravings can be found in the Philippines. Charcoal rock paintings are known from Peñablanca Caves in Cagayan Valley and Ugpay Cave in the Singnapan Basin in Ransang, Palawan as well as paintings made by using red hematite, known from Anda Peninsula, Bohol Province.

Excavations of the rock shelter produced mainly remains from the Neolithic and Palaeolithic. Palaeolithic pebble tools, but also coarse and low-fired pottery fragments, tortoise shells, and Neolithic polished adzes were found in front of the rock shelter. Since the majority of finds can be allocated to the Neolithic it is assumed that the petroglyphs also date to the Neolithic (between 2000 and 3000 BC). A well-preserved adze can be viewed at the museum’s exhibition.

This view is also confirmed by comparison with other dated sites in Thailand, Sulawesi, and Malaysia.

As already mentioned, the figures consist mostly of anthropomorphs, tortoises (?), and geometric motifs. Alphabetic writings were added in recent times and show the continuing attraction the rock shelter presented.

Even the modern tunnel leading to the museum and petroglyph site is full of carvings:

Although we cannot know the purpose of these signs we know that apart from profane reasons like looking for shelter and protection, caves and rock shelters were often used for burials and/or offerings. The famous Duyong burial in Palawan was a Neolithic burial that was included into an already existing shell midden inside the cave. Polished adzes were part of his funerary kit, but also tridacna shell adzes. The teeth of the young man were stained and presented the first evidence of betel nut chewing. But also the late Neolithic early metal ages jar burials can be found in caves as well as coffin burials.

Even older are the remains of a cremation burial in Ille Cave, Palawan. This burial of a young woman was incorporated in an existing shell midden, too. Radiocarbon dates gave an age of 7000 BC (Lewis et al. 2008).

In Angono, no skeletons have been found during the excavations and since the excavation reports are not easily accessible outside of the Philippines, I do not know whether Angono rock shelter was used as a living space or rather had ritual significance. Were the adze pieces deliberately broken and/or subjected to fire? Are tortoise shells rare in cave sites? After all Angono rock shelter is 235 m above sea level. Have the shells been found in a limited concentration which could suggest feasting events similar to the upbuilding of shell middens? Were the pots smashed? I cannot say, but I know that the Angono site had a special meaning for the Neolithic population in order to come up here time after time and carve the walls of the rock shelter.

Location: 14°31’58.34″N 121°11’12.46″E

Lewis et al. 2008. Terminal Pleistocene to mid-Holocene occupation and an early cremation burial at Ille Cave, Palawan, Philippines, Antiquity 82, 318-35.

Peralta, Jesus T. 1973. The Petroglyphs of the Angono Rockshelter, Rizal, Philippines. Master Thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of the Philippines, Diliman. Philippines National Museum.

Exploring the pre-historic Angono petroglyphs (blog post)

Philippines National Museum

Rupe Magna, Grosio, Valtellina, Italy

Rupe Magna (‘Big Rock’) is an 84 m long and 35 m wide rock surface which was polished by glaciers and heavily engraved during prehistoric times. The first figures belong to the final Neolithic and/or Copper Age(spirals, arcs etc.). In the Bronze Age anthropomorphic figures were added, the so-called oranti (praying figures, because they hold their arms up as if in prayer). The figures developed into fighting scenes during the Iron Age and there are even some crosses from historic times.There are more than 5000 figures engraved on this rock panel with about 60 % just cupules and lines and 30 % anthropomorphic figures. Representations of animals are scarce. It is the largest engraved rock in the Alps.

Although 83 % of the engravings are assignable to the Iron Age, the first figures belong to the final Neolithic and/or Copper Age. These consist mostly of cup and ring marks, lines or lines which are  combined to arc like motifs.

In the Bronze Age anthropomorphic figures started to be added, the so-called oranti (praying figures, because the hold their arms up as if in prayer).

Here is a figure to show you in more detail what is depicted. It was a rainy day and therefore the petroglyphs are not as visible as they are on sunny mornings or evenings when there is a deep shadow outlining the figures.

Rupe Magna, Grosio, Lombardy, Italy. Outline of anthropomorphic figure.

The figures developed into armed figures and even fighting scenes during the Iron Age and some crosses from historic times document a late use, although probably only to de-devilish the site as it was done in other areas. Representations of animals are scarce.

On the Rupestre.net webpage you can find this excellent chronological table for the Rupe Magna:

Most anthropomorphic figures were made during the Bronze Age, a time when the site was already settled. Excavations at the castle site showed that it was settled at least from the beginning of the  Bronze Age. Here the stratigraphy from the excavation (the dark red colour symbolises the prehistoric, mainly Bronze Age, settlement):

Castello Visconti near Rupe Magna. Site stratigraphy

There is also an undeniable connection to Situla art, especially the depiction of fist fights with dumb-bells. Situlas can be found not only in the Etruscan area of influence but even more so  in the complete Eastern Hallstatt Culture, especially Istria and Slovenia, and as imported goods even in Germany and beyond.

http://www.lessing-photo.com/p2/070103/07010351.jpg

In 1978 a consortium for the protection and study of the engravings was established and there is a small museum, called the ‘Antiquarium’ near the site which displays objects from the excavations of the castle site. A bookshop is also present.

Further reading:

Arcà, A. et al. 1995. Rupe Magna, la roccia incisa piú grande delle Alpi, Sondrio.

http://www.rupestre.net/alps/valt_rupe.html

Some Archaeology in Oxfordshire

If you are interested in some photos from our trip to England, go

Rollright Stones, Oxfordshire

here for the Rollright Stones, the King Stone, and the Whispering Knights in Oxfordshire and Warwickshire,

Uffington White Horse

here for Uffington Horse and the Uffington Castle hill fort,

Wayland's Smithy long barrow

and here for Wayland’s Smithy and Lambourn Seven Barrows, all in Oxfordshire.

Khufu’s expeditions – Die Expeditionen des Cheops

Apart from the Great Pyramid Complex in Saqqara few buildings and artefacts relate directly to Khufu’s reign. Later descriptions and stories like the Westcar Papyrus (probably Middle Kingdom) and the writings of Herodotus (5th century BC)1 and Manetho (3rd century BC)2 were written many centuries after Khufu’s death and developed over time into distorted descriptions of a cruel and godless pharaoh. Since there are no contemporary sources, few details of his life are actually known. One puzzle piece in Khufu’s life, however, is the recently discovered inscriptions of expeditions and mining activities of Khufu. These signs, sometimes not more than a cartouche or a simple text, can nonetheless give us important information about Khufu’s ambitions and ideas concerning his role as pharaoh, his relationship with the ‘enemies of Egypt’, the outside, and even social changes within Egypt.

pdf file with a short essay about Khufu’s expeditions (written by me):

Khufu’s expeditions – Die Expeditionen des Cheops

Jüngst entdeckte Inschriften aus der Regierungszeit des Pharao Cheops welche über militärische Expeditionen und Steinbrucharbeiten berichten bilden eine neue ergänzende Quelle für eine ansonsten wenig bekannte Zeit des Alten Reiches. Aus der Zeit Cheops gibt es abgesehen von der nach ihm benannten Cheopspyramide nur wenige Bauwerke und Artefakte.

Photo by J.P. Sébah (1838-1890) published by Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Spätere Beschreibungen und Erzählungen wie die Berichte des Herodot (5. Jahrhundert v. Chr.) oder des Manetho (3. Jahrhundert v. Chr.) wurden erst viele Jahrhunderte nach dem Tode Cheops niedergeschrieben und geben nur eine verzerrte Beschreibung des wahren Cheops wieder. Durch die Inschriften und archäologischen Überreste seiner Expeditionen erschließt sich uns eine neue Bewertungsgrundlage für diesen außergwähnlichen Herrscher und seine Zeit.

Das beigefügte pdf file (leider nur in Englisch) gibt eine Übersicht über seine Expeditionen und was die neu gewonnenen Informationen für eine Interpretation bezüglich der Ambitionen Khufus, seiner Vorstellung über die Rolle des Pharaos, seine Beziehung zu den ‘Feinden’ Ägyptens und der nichtägyptischen Außenwelt und selbst über die sozialen Veränderung der ägyptischen Gesellschaft zulassen.

The main inscription at Khufu 01/01 recording an expedition of two officers in Khufu’s 27th regnal year. On the right a representation of the oasis god Igai.Preliminary Report on the Field Season 2002 of the ACACIA Project in the Western Desert published by the Sonderforschungsbereich SFB 389, University of Cologne

pdf file mit einem kurzen Essay (englisch)  über die Expeditionen Cheops (von mir geschrieben):

Khufu’s expeditions – Die Expeditionen des Cheops

 

Top articles Febuary 2011: Wilmshurst et al., High-precision radiocarbon dating shows recent and rapid initial human colonization of East Polynesia

A German version can be found here.

I wish journal editors would insist on short titles for articles *sigh*. But anyway, my second article in the top 3 list is a publication on the colonization of Eastern Polynesia. Four top-class scientist came together to re-examine and evaluate radiocarbon data to get a better picture of the colonization of Eastern Polynesia: Janet Wilmshurst from the government owned Landcare Research, an environmental and research organisation in New Zealand; Wilmshurst is probably best known for her work on Pacific rats but has a wide field of interests, Terry Hunt from the Anthropology Department at University of Hawaii, who is engaged in ongoing research on Rapa Nui, Carl Lipo from the Department of Anthropology in Long Beach and co-founder of the IIRMES institute whose  interest in development of theoretical models to study patterns of change clearly showed in this article, and last not least Atholl Anderson from the ANU college of Asia & the Pacific, who is currently directing a major program on Initial Colonization in the Indo-Pacific Region.

There has been a long debate about how and in which time frame Polynesia has been settled with various partially contradicting theories. To address the conflicting chronologies Wilmshurst et al. reverted to a simple yet as it showed, extremely effective method. They sighted the available radiocarbon dates and sorted them into reliability classes. The most reliable data (which the authors named “class 1″) from short lived plants and terrestrial bird eggshells with marginal errors (to circumvent the substantial wiggle in the calibration curve) were then contrasted to less reliable radiocarbon dates, partially taken from samples without any connection materials or commensals like the Pacific rat.

This was the general view of colonization dates for Polynesia (photo from a poster display at the Bishop museum, Honolulu):

 Presuming a starting point in Samoa and Tonga from which the settlement of the Eastern islands started around 800 BC (Wilmshurst et al. 2011, 1818) Wilmshurst et al. could demonstrate that class 1 data had a very short chronology of settlement for all islands including far off ones like Rapa Nui and New Zealand. In short, the authors could establish two migrational phases: a first one to the Society Islands and possibly as far as Gambier at around AD 1025 to 1121 (orange shading on the map) and a second one to every other island in East Polynesia at AD 1200 to 1290.

Wilmshurst et al. 2011, fig.1

Their findings will have an immense impact on studies of settlement patterns in Polynesia. Some chronologies could be confirmed (e.g. New Zealand and Rapa Nui) other colonizing chronologies were shortened and pushed back in date by several hundred years (e.g. the Marquesas, Hawaiian archipelago). The most astonishing result from their study is the uniform timing of the expansion to even the remotest islands like Auckland Island, Hawaii, or Rapa Nui.

The authors then offer different cultural based explanations for the new settlement chronology like population growth, purposeful explorations with the help of technical innovations but also environmental factors or disasters; they here mention the peak El Niño in the 13th century but one can also think of volcanic eruptions although the source eruption for the AD 1259 eruption is still unknown and the Kaharoa, New Zealand eruption dates to the early 14th century and is therefore too late to be taken into consideration.

In a final point they address problems that need urgent reconsideration in respect of the new data set, as there are:

  • introduction of sweet potatoes
  • linguistics
  • artefact similarities
  • human impact on island ecosystems (deforestation, plant and animal extinctions)

Their list could be expanded to genetics (cp. Brewis et al. 1995, Asia Pacific J Clin Nutr 4, 361-5), appearance and stylistic of monumental architecture, dating of rock art to name but a few. There is hope,  that this will be a stimulus to new research into these problems in order to re-analyse present conceptions.

Overall an excellent article that showed how you can make a big step forward in a stagnating topic just by reviewing radiocarbon dates. I was very surprised to find that five islands completely lacked class 1 data and apart from New Zealand reliable radiocarbon dates are the exception instead of the rule. It also reminds us to question the reliability of C14 dates anew when trying to establish cultural development over time.

Only two minor points of critique are left on my side. One is the idea of el Niño events as driving force behind the direction of colonization. Already in the first phase migrations spread considerably to the east, while only very mild el Niño effects have been described for this period (Crowley 2000, Science 289, 2707; Mann et al. 2003, Eos 84, 256-8); The second phase is marked by a spread not only towards the east, but also towards the north and southwest. Since colonization happened within a very short period of time as the authors have demonstrated, it is unlikely that increased westerly and/or easterly winds could be responsible alone.

The second is the attribution of the island of Rapa Nui to the second phase of colonization. In fig . 3 of the article they compare the radiocarbon dates and Rapa Nui has nearly as early dates as Gambier and the Society islands. In my view they could also qualify for the early phase. Besides, if we are considering the normal oceanic circulation

 (see picture), then the equatorial counter current would have brought a maritime sailor right to the border of the American continent and hence also possibly to Rapa Nui.

 I want to conclude with a citation by the authors:

“…previously supported implications that there was a long period of relatively benign interaction among humans, rats, dogs, pigs, and indigenous vertebrates now need revision, as our refined model of colonization chronology suggests that impacts had to have been immediate, severe, and continuous.”

Maybe we can learn something for our future, because this is exactly what human impact always seems to be: immediate, severe, and continuous.

Full citation of article: J M Wilmshurst, T L Hunt, C P Lipo, and A J Anderson, High-precision radiocarbon dating shows recent and rapid initial human colonization of East Polynesia, PNAS 108 (5), 2011, 1815-20.

This article is available online through the PNAS open access option.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.